Israel Gambling License
Gambling with the Jewish Law
- Israel Gambling License Application
- Israel Gambling License Requirements
- Israel Gambling License Laws
- Israel Gambling License Plate
by Yehudah Poznick
A Fresh New Face for Aristocrat’s Gaming Business. News 14 August 2020. IAG Inside Asian Gaming Features Aristocrat – Putting People First. Game Releases 14 August 2020. Casino Bad Oeynhausen blows whistle on European launch of Aristocrat’s Cash Express Luxury Line™ News 28 April 2020. Supporting Our Communities In Times Of Need. Gambling may be popular among Israeli players, however, there are only two types of gambling which have been legalized. The Israeli government only permit citizens to play their National Lottery.
During the last elections in Israel approximately three years ago, over thirty political parties ran for seats in the Knesset, the Israeli Parliament. One of them, 'The Casino Party', had a very provocative platform: to legalize casino gambling in Israel. Some of the reasons for such legalization were as follows:
1) to compete with the tremendously successful Palestinian casino in Jericho, which was to be followed by another in Tull-Karm,
2) to keep the Israelis' hard-earned money in Israeli hands, which could help fund various social programs (as does the lottery presently),
3) to provide people with jobs, and undoubtedly other rationalizations.
Israel Gambling License Application
But, the arguments against were also strong:
1) casino gambling has a certain association with organized crime--why actively assist Mafioso's with another means of making money,
2) the addictive nature of gambling, and the possibility of only creating another ill of society, and
3) legalizing it somewhat 'koshers' an otherwise dishonest means of making money--what difference is there between casino gambling and someone ripping people off at three-card-Monty (which is illegal in many areas where gambling has been legitimized).
Let's have a look (hardly an exhaustive one) of what Jewish traditional sources say about gambling and how honest it is:
The Talmud lists the following people as invalid to serve as witnesses, and all the more so to serve as judges:
* Dice players--i.e., people who live off winnings from gambling
* People who lend out money on interest
* Pigeon raisers (two reasons given as to why this is problematic:
1) they train their pigeons to attract other people's pigeons--even if the other person only captured pigeons and never paid for them, still it is dishonest
2) they use them to race against other pigeons--another example of forbidden gambling)
* Those who do business with produce of the Sabbatical year (which has a certain degree of sanctity to it, and is forbidden for commercial use, but is rather to be declared ownerless and free to all)
Israel Gambling License Requirements
Rabbi Yehudah qualifies the above-mentioned list: this only applies if they have no other occupation other than this--if they earn an honest livelihood by some other means, they are still valid to serve as witnesses and judges.
Rashi, the major commentator on the Talmud, explains that Rabbi Yehudah is coming to tell us that the reason for these people being invalid is that they do nothing to actively to promote settlement of the world by means of a productive livelihood. They therefore lack the sensitivity to what is proper and just, are ignorant of proper business practice, and are therefore deficient in fear of G-d.
The Talmud entertains another possibility why to invalidate dice players--asmachta--'reliance': the money he is willing to gamble in the course of the dice game is laid out unwillingly, only insofar as to put a stake on his opponent's money. He is relying on something (winning the dice game) which presently has no basis in fact, to gain profit. The Rabbis set the rule that 'asmachta lo kanyia' there is no acquisition in this case Therefore the money he puts down in the game is not relinquished whole-heartedly. If he should win his opponent's money, it is considered theft to some extent. (One major point to permit lottery winnings is the fact that those who buy lottery tickets know that if they lose, the money will go to all sorts of social programs, so they accept the loss, at least after the fact.)
The Talmud commentators make an interesting distinction: if the game is purely one of luck, with no skill involved (e.g., a slot machine), the money gambled is relinquished at the very beginning of the game, so that the winnings are not classified as theft. If the participants are also relying on their skill, (for example, backgammon, which involves skill, an element of luck, and the doubling cube--outright gambling) it means that the players do not whole-heartedly giving up their money in the case of a loss. A person who plays backgammon always puts down the money because he thinks he's more skilled than his opponent, and even if he should lose, will always feel that he was cheated. So it's a problem of theft if the opponent makes use of the earnings.
Some practical examples are if a person gambles, and makes no use of the earnings, but has them ear-marked as for more gambling, and gambles just as a pastime:
If one has no livelihood but lives from investments, and he gambles just as a pastime, making no use of the earnings other than for more gambling:
Maimonides (known also as the Rambam) would rule that he's fit to serve as a witness, since there's no theft involved--the very money he won today, he could lose tomorrow.
Rashi, however, who doesn't emphasize the theft aspect, but rather that of not actively working to settle the world by productive work, would rule oppositely: the person who doesn't work at all, and just passes his time with gambling, is invalid to serve as a witness--he doesn't sufficiently appreciate the value of money, and may easily be bribed if he serves as a witness, or will not appreciate the importance of the money at stake, since he uses the money only as a means of making the game more interesting.
If one has another livelihood, but it doesn't provide enough income:
Maimonides would say we must assume that he's living off the gains from his gambling, and the money is earned through something that borders on theft
But Rashi would rule that one works at least a little bit, but gambles to earn extra money, would be allowed to serve as a witness, since he understands the meaning of money, and knows what is at stake in the trial.
A medieval rabbi in Italy, Rabbi Leon de Modena, had a very great penchant for gambling, despite all the above-mentioned legal problems with the earnings. Sensing that there's a problem with his hobby, he wrote a dialogue where he proves to his 'opponent' that someone who is addicted to gambling can, if not careful, end up transgressing all of the Ten Commandments. Once a person gets involved in gambling, he could get involved in various dubious schemes for making quick money and from there it is a short step to all negative activities.
Or, a person has losses to cover, and someone offers him money to serve as a witness in a court case. He really didn't witness the transaction he is told to attest to--but again the dollar signs dancing in front of his eyes cloud his better judgment.
In short, if a person who otherwise earns a good living puts down money in a game just to relax a little bit having a leisurely game with some friends, and the money used is purely for increasing interest in the game, with no-one really expecting to rake in the other guys' money, that would be fine. However, the game must not reach the point of an addiction--one should always keep his sights on the fact that it is just a game.
~~~~~~~from the February 2003 Edition of the Jewish Magazine
A common complaint relating to gambling legislation in many parts of the world is that it’s very confusing. There are several regions where the laws aren’t at all explicit, and the actual legality of gambling is something of a grey area.
This isn’t an issue in Russia, because their gambling laws are perfectly clear.
Online gambling is completely banned in Russia, as is land based gambling in all but four regions of the country. It doesn’t appear that this is likely to change any time in the near future either, although it is believed many Russians do continue to gamble online.
On this page, we take a look at how the gambling laws in Russia have changed over the years, and what they mean for anyone wanting to gamble in this country.
Brief History of Russian Gambling Laws
In 1928, when Russia was under Soviet Rule, all forms of gambling were banned. This was the case until the late 1980s. Slot machines were legalized in certain locations in 1988, and the gambling ban was lifted completely in the following year.
Land based casinos began to open, and by 2002 there were over 50 operating in Moscow alone.
As the popularity of gambling rose, and there was little regulation in place, the government took steps to control the activity. In 2006, they passed a law which prohibited all forms of online gambling.
Up until this point, the majority of gambling sites welcomed Russian customers. Many of them continued to do so, despite this legislation.
In 2009, under Vladimir Putin, land based gambling was restricted to four zones: Kaliningrad Oblast, Krasnador Krai, Altai Krai, and Primorsky Krai. Gambling in all other parts of the country was banned, which remains the case today.
A ruling from the Russian Supreme Court, in 2012, took the online gambling prohibition a step further. It stated that internet service providers must block sites operated by online gambling operators, with a view to making it impossible for Russians to access their services.
Israel Gambling License Laws
Internet providers had previously refused to do this, and had even won a lawsuit brought against them trying to enforce them, but this ruling threatened them with the loss of their licenses if they didn’t comply.
Israel Gambling License Plate
Later in 2012, the Roskomnadzor was made public. This is a list which details all the sites which are deemed illegal by the Russian government. It features a number of domains belonging to international gambling operators, including some of the biggest names.
As a result, some of these operators closed their virtual doors to Russian customers.
Some operators continued to provide their services to Russian customers though, and interestingly the government hasn’t yet taken steps to block financial transactions. They do seem to be committed to preventing online gambling in any way possible however.
The Roskomnadzor also contains sites that don’t directly provide gambling services; they provide information on gambling related topics as well.
The strict anti-gambling laws make it clear that you are breaking the law if you choose to gamble online. There’s some debate about whether poker falls under this law, due to the argument that it’s a game of skill rather than a game of chance, but casino games and sports betting certainly do.
With that being said, it appears unlikely that you are facing the prospect of prosecution if you do. While the government has the right to do so, their focus seems to be on going after those facilitating online gambling rather than those that actually partake in it.
Domestic operators are prohibited from offering online gambling services and, as we’ve mentioned, internet service providers are required to block gambling sites operated overseas.
It’s this last point that makes it difficult to gamble online from Russia, although not every single gambling site is on the blacklist that internet service providers have to block.
Changes to Russian Online Gambling Legislation
We will report any changes to Russian online gambling legislation here, along with other updates which may affect online gamblers in Russia.